Biomedicines Journal (MDPI), Special Issue: Omics Data Analysis and Integration in Complex Diseases (April 2022)
by Sara M. de Cripan (Computational Metabolomics for Systems Biology Lab, Omics Sciences Unit, Eurecat—Technology Centre of Catalonia; Centre for Omics Sciences (COS), Eurecat—Technology Centre of Catalonia & Rovira i Virgili University Joint Unit; Department of Electrical, Electronic and Control Engineering (DEEEA), Universitat Rovira i Virgili); Adrià Cereto-Massagué (Centre for Omics Sciences (COS), Eurecat—Technology Centre of Catalonia & Rovira i Virgili University Joint Unit); Pol Herrero (Centre for Omics Sciences (COS), Eurecat—Technology Centre of Catalonia & Rovira i Virgili University Joint Unit); Andrei Barcaru (Independent Researcher); Núria Canela (Centre for Omics Sciences (COS), Eurecat—Technology Centre of Catalonia & Rovira i Virgili University Joint Unit); Xavier Domingo-Almenara (Computational Metabolomics for Systems Biology Lab, Omics Sciences Unit, Eurecat—Technology Centre of Catalonia; Centre for Omics Sciences (COS), Eurecat—Technology Centre of Catalonia & Rovira i Virgili University Joint Unit; Department of Electrical, Electronic and Control Engineering (DEEEA), Universitat Rovira i Virgili)
Abstract
In gas chromatography–mass spectrometry-based untargeted metabolomics, metabolites are identified by comparing mass spectra and chromatographic retention time with reference databases or standard materials. In that sense, machine learning has been used to predict the retention time of metabolites lacking reference data. However, the retention time prediction of trimethylsilyl derivatives of metabolites, typically analyzed in untargeted metabolomics using gas chromatography, has been poorly explored. Here, we provide a rationalized framework for machine learning-based retention time prediction of trimethylsilyl derivatives of metabolites in gas chromatography. We compared different machine learning paradigms, in addition to exploring the influence of the computational molecular structure representation to train the prediction models: fingerprint class and fingerprint calculation software. Our study challenged predicted retention time when using chemical ionization and electron impact ionization sources in simulated and real cases, demonstrating a good correct identity ranking capability by machine learning, despite observing a limited false identity filtering power in cases where a spectrum or a monoisotopic mass match to multiple candidates. Specifically, machine learning prediction yielded median absolute and relative retention index (relative retention time) errors of 37.1 retention index units and 2%, respectively. In addition, fingerprint class and fingerprint calculation software, as well as the molecular structural similarity between the training and test or real case sets, showed to be critical modulators of the prediction performance. Finally, we leveraged the structural similarity between the training and test or real case set to determine the probability that the prediction error is below a specific threshold. Overall, our study demonstrates that predicted retention time can provide insights into the true structure of unknown metabolites by ranking from the most to the least plausible molecular identity, and sets the guidelines to assess the confidence in metabolite identification using predicted retention time data.